JOHN MAGARO is a prolific actor in film, television, and theatre. Recent appearances include a leading role in Tim Fehlbaum’s Oscar-nominated SEPTEMBER 5 (2024), which celebrated its world premiere in Venice and was nominated for a Golden Globe for Best Film. He just premiered in Sundance with OMAHA (2025) by Cole Webley. Maggie Gyllenhaal’s Frankenstein story THE BRIDE! (2025), in which he stars alongside Jessie Buckley, Christian Bale, Jake Gyllenhaal, Penélope Cruz and Peter Sarsgaard, as well as Kelly Reichardt’s THE MASTERMIND (2025) are forthcoming. He also has a role in the series “The Agency” (2024). John’s previous films include Celine Song’s PAST LIVES (2023), THE SHALLOW TALE OF A WRITER WHO DECIDED TO WRITE ABOUT A SERIAL KILLER (2024) by Tolga Karaçelik, DAY OF THE FIGHT (2023) by Jack Huston, LaROY, TEXAS (2023) by Shane Atkinson, BIG GEORGE FOREMAN (2023) by George Tillman Jr., Kelly Reichardt’s SHOWING UP (2022) with Michelle Williams (Cannes 2022), and CALL JANE by Phyllis Nagy (Sundance 2022). Magaro played a supporting role in THE MANY SAINTS OF NEWARK (2021), the prequel to the series “The Sopranos”, which reunited him with David Chase. Magaro already worked with Kelly Reichardt on her FIRST COW (Telluride 2019 and 70. Berlinale). At the 2020 New York Film Critics Circle Awards, “First Cow” was named Best Picture, and the National Board of Review selected it as one of the ten best films of that year. Magaro was nominated for a Gotham Award for his acting performance.
Magaro also starred in Adam McKay’s THE BIG SHORT (2015), whose ensemble was awarded by the National Board of Review and the Palm Springs Film Festival in 2015. As part of the ensemble, Magaro was also nominated for a Critics Choice Award and SAG Award.
Other titles in his filmography include THE FINEST HOURS (2016) by Craig Gillespie, CAROL (2015) by Todd Haynes, UNBROKEN (2014) by Angelina Jolie, NOT FADE AWAY (2012) by David Chase, which earned him the Hollywood Spotlight Award at the Hollywood Film Awards, LIBERAL ARTS (2012) by Josh Radnor, DOWN THE SHORE (2011) by Harold Guskin, MY SOUL TO TAKE (2010) by Wes Craven, THE BOX (2009) by Richard Kelly, LONG LEGS, SHORT LIES (2008) by Brett Simon, THE LIFE BEFORE MY EYES (2007) by Vadim Perelman and THE STRANGER IN YOU (2007) by Neil Jordan. Magaro’s television credits include “The Umbrella Academy” based on the comic book series of the same name by Gerard Way, the Amazon series “Tom Clancy’s Jack Ryan” alongside John Krasinski and “Crisis In Six Scenes” alongside Rachel Brosnahan, Miley Cyrus, and Elaine May. He played recurring roles in series such as “Orange Is the New Black”, “The Good Wife” or “Taking Chance” with Kevin Bacon. He has made guest appearances in “Law & Order: SVU”, “Person of Interest”, “Body of Proof”, “Law & Order” and “Conviction”.
On stage, Magaro was seen at The Public Theater as Joe Papp in “Illyria” by Richard Nelson. He made his Broadway debut in a remarkable supporting role in the new production of Scott Rudin’s “The Front Page” directed by Jack O’Brien. He also played the male lead in the critically acclaimed “Tigers Be Still” by writer Kimberly Rosenstock and director Sam Gold for the Roundabout Theatre Company and was part of the ensemble of Rod McLauchlan’s “Good Television” in a production by Bob Krakower for the Atlantic Theater Company.